Progressive Auto Insurance Review [2020]

Progressive auto insurance reviews find the company with an "A+" financial rating from A.M. Best and an "A-" with the Better Business Bureau. As the third-largest insurance company in the country, Progressive auto insurance rates are among the cheapest and most competitive. Your personal Progressive auto insurance quote will be influenced by the kind of car you drive and where you live. Read our review to compare Progressive auto insurance costs by the make and model of your vehicle, then enter your ZIP code below to get a your free insurance quote online.

FREE Car Insurance Comparison

Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Rachel Bodine graduated from college with a BA in English. She works as an associate editor and writer for 4autoinsurancequote.com for over a year and enjoys creating content that offers expert advice on car insurance topics.

Full Bio →

Written by

Leslie Kasperowicz holds a BA in Social Sciences from the University of Winnipeg. She spent several years as a Farmers Insurance CSR, gaining a solid understanding of insurance products including home, life, auto, and commercial and working directly with insurance customers to understand their needs...

Full Bio →

Reviewed byLeslie Kasperowicz
Former Farmers Insurance CSRhttps://res.cloudinary.com/quotellc/image/upload/insurance-site-images/4autoins-live/6ea5d860-leslie-kasperowicz.jpg

UPDATED: Sep 24, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn't influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Progressive OverviewProgressive Stats
Year Founded1937
Current ExecutivesTricia Griffith, CEO & President
John Barbagallo Commercial Lines President
Total Sales$10 billion USD per year
Headquarters6300 Wilson Mills Rd.
Mayfield Village, Ohio 44143
Phone Number1 (800) 776-4737
(Customer Service)
Company Websitehttps://www.progressive.com/
Premiums Written$27,058,768,000
Loss Ratio62
Best ForAuto Insurance
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Car insurance is part of the total cost of living for most U.S. citizens. If you’re going to drive a vehicle, you’ll need car insurance.

You may have read through some of our state and city guides and have come across some of the cheapest rates in your state. Progressive is one of the insurance companies that offer affordable rates and discounts, making insurance more cost-efficient for people who want to cut the total annual cost of insurance.

This guide will give you information on everything you need to know about Progressive car insurance, from average annual rates and discounts to how to make a quote online.

If you want to compare quotes from different quotes right away, enter your ZIP code in the free quote box above. For more information about Progressive car insurance, continue through the guide.

Table of Contents

Cheap Car Insurance Rates

This section of the guide talks about the car insurance premium a potential customer is likely to pay as a policyholder. Car insurance premiums (or rates) vary based on different factors such as age, gender, marital status, type of vehicle, commute rates, coverage level, credit history, and driving history.

In addition to these factors, annual premiums are different for each state. We’ll cover each of these factors and analyze the data so you can review which rates are the cheapest.

Progressive Availability and Rates by State

Based on our in-house data, Progressive is available in all U.S. states. Each state has an average annual rate for all insurance companies, while Progressive has an average annual rate of its own. In the information provided in this section, we’ll compare the state averages for car insurance and Progressive’s average rates for each state.

We do this for each of our company guides to show how much more or less car insurance is in each state. Let’s begin by looking at the data. Use the search bar on the upper right corner to find your state.

Average Annual Progressive Auto Insurance Rates by State

Average Annual Progressive Auto Insurance Rates by State
StatesProgressive Average Annual RatesState Average Annual RatesDifferences in Average Rates ($)Differences in Average Rates (%)
Hawaii$2,177.93$2,555.64-$377.71-14.78%
North Carolina$2,382.61$3,393.11-$1,010.50-29.78%
Iowa$2,395.50$2,981.28-$585.78-19.65%
Virginia$2,498.58$2,357.87$140.715.97%
New Hampshire$2,694.45$3,151.77-$457.32-14.51%
California$2,849.67$3,688.93-$839.26-22.75%
Alaska$3,062.85$3,421.51-$358.66-10.48%
New Mexico$3,119.18$3,463.64-$344.46-9.94%
Wisconsin$3,128.91$3,606.06-$477.15-13.23%
Washington$3,209.52$3,059.32$150.204.91%
Missouri$3,419.14$3,328.93$90.212.71%
Ohio$3,436.96$2,709.71$727.2526.84%
Illinois$3,536.65$3,305.48$231.176.99%
Arizona$3,577.50$3,770.97-$193.47-5.13%
North Dakota$3,623.06$4,165.84-$542.78-13.03%
Oregon$3,629.13$3,467.77$161.364.65%
Maine$3,643.59$2,953.28$690.3223.37%
Tennessee$3,656.91$3,660.89-$3.98-0.11%
South Dakota$3,752.81$3,982.27-$229.46-5.76%
Nebraska$3,758.01$3,283.68$474.3314.44%
New York$3,771.15$4,289.88-$518.73-12.09%
Utah$3,830.10$3,611.89$218.216.04%
Massachusetts$3,835.11$2,678.85$1,156.2643.16%
Indiana$3,898.00$3,414.97$483.0314.14%
Median$3,935.36$3,660.89$274.477.50%
New Jersey$3,972.72$5,515.21-$1,542.49-27.97%
Nevada$4,062.57$4,861.70-$799.13-16.44%
Maryland$4,094.86$4,582.70-$487.84-10.65%
Kansas$4,144.38$3,279.62$864.7626.37%
Delaware$4,181.83$5,986.32-$1,804.49-30.14%
Colorado$4,231.92$3,876.39$355.539.17%
Mississippi$4,308.85$3,664.57$644.2817.58%
Montana$4,330.76$3,220.84$1,109.9234.46%
Wyoming$4,401.17$3,200.08$1,201.0937.53%
Alabama$4,450.52$3,566.96$883.5624.77%
Pennsylvania$4,451.00$4,034.50$416.5110.32%
Georgia$4,499.22$4,966.83-$467.61-9.41%
South Carolina$4,573.08$3,781.14$791.9420.94%
Texas$4,664.69$4,043.28$621.4115.37%
Oklahoma$4,832.35$4,142.33$690.0316.66%
Connecticut$4,920.35$4,618.92$301.436.53%
District of Columbia$4,970.26$4,439.24$531.0211.96%
Vermont$5,217.14$3,234.13$1,983.0161.32%
Rhode Island$5,231.09$5,003.36$227.734.55%
Arkansas$5,312.09$4,124.98$1,187.1128.78%
Michigan$5,364.55$10,498.64-$5,134.09-48.90%
Kentucky$5,547.63$5,195.40$352.236.78%
Florida$5,583.30$4,680.46$902.8419.29%
Louisiana$7,471.10$5,711.34$1,759.7630.81%
West Virginia-$2,595.36--
Idaho-$2,979.09--
Minnesota-$4,403.25--
Get Your Rates Quote Now

If you click on the up-triangle, you’ll be able to sort the table from lowest to highest. Idaho, Minnesota, and West Virginia don’t have any data. If you live in one of those three states, contact a local Progressive agent in those areas about car insurance rates.

For some states that do have values, car insurance from Progressive is much more expensive per year. For example, in Florida, Progressive is $903 more than the Florida average rate. The percentage listed is the difference between Florida’s average annual rate and Florida’s Progressive average annual rate.

Comparing the Top 10 Companies by Market Share

Where does Progressive stand in market share? We talked about the rankings before and how they are determined by market share. Progressive has earned its spot among the top insurance companies, but how does the company compare to its competitors? Let’s look at how Progressive compares to the other major companies in the country.

Top U.S. Car Insurance Companies by Market Share
Top Car Insurance CompaniesAverage Annual PremiumsMarket Share
State Farm$2,731.4817.01%
Geico$3,073.6613.41%
Progressive$3,935.3610.97%
Allstate$4,532.969.19%
USAA$2,489.495.87%
Liberty Mutual$5,295.554.77%
Farmers$3,907.994.26%
Nationwide$3,187.202.73%
Travelers$3,729.321.9%
American Family$3,698.771.9%
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Progressive has the third-largest market share when compared to the other car insurance companies in the country.

Average Progressive Male vs. Female Car Insurance Rates

When you’re shopping for car insurance, you should know that car insurance companies base your premiums on several factors. Some of those factors include your age, gender, and marital status. As of Aug. 1, 2019, California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Montana, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, and parts of Michigan have outlawed car insurance companies from using age, gender, and marital status to determine car insurance rates.

For the states that still follow this car insurance factor, there are annual rates that come with it. We’ve collected some data, which is presented in the table below.

Demographics (Age, Gender & Marital Status)Progressive Annual Rates Based on Demographics
Single 17-year-old female$8,689.95
Single 17-year-old male$9,625.49
Single 25-year-old female$2,697.73
Single 25-year-old male$2,758.66
Married 35-year-old female$2,296.90
Married 35-year-old male$2,175.27
Married 60-year-old female$1,991.49
Married 60-year-old male$2,048.63
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The average annual rate for teen drivers is nearly $10,000. Progressive does have discount options to curve the price a little more, but the annual rate for teen drivers is more expensive than any other demographic. Older, married drivers pay significantly less than single and younger drivers. How come?

Statistics show that younger drivers take more risks while in a motor vehicle. Young male drivers are likely to take even more risks, and car insurance companies have to assess the risk based on crash statistics.

Average Progressive Rates by Make and Model

Have you ever noticed how car insurance rates vary by vehicle? Older vehicles tend to have cheaper annual rates. The values of the vehicles often reflect the car insurance rates. Therefore, new make and model vehicles will cost more to insure. Here’s a table that shows how much Progressive may issue for car insurance based on the make and model of a vehicle.

Make and Model of a VehicleProgressive Annual Rates based on Make and Model
2015 Ford F-150: Lariat SuperCab with 2WD 6.5 foot bed and 2.7L V6$3,914.05
2015 Honda Civic Sedan: LX with 2.0L 4cyl and CVT$4,429.56
2015 Toyota RAV4: XLE$3,647.22
2018 Ford F-150: Lariat SuperCab with 2WD 6.5 foot bed and 2.7L V6$3,962.58
2018 Honda Civic Sedan: LX with 2.0L 4cyl and CVT$4,528.90
2018 Toyota RAV4: XLE$3,730.78
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Let’s look at the Toyota RAV4 XLE and compare the car insurance premiums from Progressive. The latest model has a more expensive annual rate, which is nearly $100 more. Expect this trend for most vehicles you take to car insurance companies to get insured.

Average Progressive Commute Rates

Commute rates are determined by the mileage a policyholder travels per year. Car insurance companies estimate mileage based on how you’ll use your vehicle. if you plan on using your vehicle for school or work commutes, you’ll likely pay more money. If the vehicle you drive is a vehicle you only take out for special occasions, you’ll probably pay the minimum commute rate.

So what are the commute rates for Progressive? Let’s examine them.

Commute Mileage SummaryProgressive Annual Rates
Based on Commute Mileage
10-mile commute, 6,000 annual miles$4,030.02
25-mile commute, 12,000 annual miles$4,041.01
Get Your Rates Quote Now

There’s not much difference in commute rates from Progressive. Policyholders could save money on discounts. Ask a Progressive agent about discounts on commute mileage rates.

Average Progressive Coverage Level Rates

Coverage level rates are based on a state’s minimum coverage requirements. For most states, that’s liability car insurance. Liability car insurance has different coverage limits, which are often known as coverage rules. Each rule has its coverage limit. Coverage limits come in different levels, and they determine the average annual rate.

Liability coverage pays for a driver’s or no-fault driver’s bodily injury and property damage. Coverage limits are the dollar amount in which a car insurance company will pay.

A low coverage level is the base car insurance coverage which is the minimum requirement for each state. Medium and high coverage levels are more expensive but have higher coverage limits.

For instance, if a driver gets into an accident and has a coverage limit that’s lower than the actual cost of bodily injury and property damage, their policy would be considered underinsured.

To avoid being underinsured, car insurance companies will suggest you get a higher coverage limit. This particularly helpful to states with low coverage limits.

Each coverage limit has its average annual rate, which we’ve listed for you in the table below.

Coverage LevelProgressive Annual Rates
Based on Coverage Level
Low$3,737.13
Medium$4,018.46
High$4,350.96
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The higher the coverage limit, the more money a policyholder will pay per year. If you live in a city where the average value of a vehicle is over $10,000, it’ll be more cost-efficient to get medium to high coverage. Most of the higher-than-average rates are decreased due to discounts.

Average Progressive Credit History Rates

Car insurance companies, including Progressive, will look at your credit history when you enroll in a policy. Credit history is an indicator that reveals your financial ability to pay the premiums for your policy. When car insurance companies look at your credit history, it’s not supposed to affect your credit rating.

Why do car insurance companies look at credit history?

Credit experts say that there’s a correlation between a person’s credit history and risk, and companies often assess whether a person is a risk based on credit history.

Does Progressive follow this trend? We can view their risk assessment as to how they issue car insurance premiums per year based on credit history. Let’s have a look.

Credit HistoryProgressive Annual Rates
Based on Credit History
Poor$4,737.64
Fair$3,956.31
Good$3,628.85
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Based on the table, Progressive does correlate credit history with risk. Those who have poor credit are likely to pay more money for car insurance than those who have fair or good credit. The national average annual rate is $3,661.

Without discounts, Progressive policyholders with poor credit will likely pay $1,100 more than the average for car insurance. If you’re in the poor credit status, ask Progressive agents for discounts to get the rate decreased.

Average Progressive Driving Record Rates

One of the most important factors of car insurance is your driving record. Accidents, speeding violations, traffic violations, and DUI convictions can increase your car insurance dramatically once they’re on your record. A person’s driving record could place them in the high-risk pool, and they’ll need SR-22 insurance to get insured.

SR-22 insurance is insurance for high-risk drivers who can’t find insurance through the voluntary market.

The voluntary market is where a potential customer of car insurance can select the company they want to get insurance. For high-risk drivers, however, their options are limited, so they must go to the DMV or other agencies that will help them acquire car insurance. The rates are generally much higher for high-risk drivers.

Drivers with a clean driving record will pay the least and receive a discount for it. There’s even some leniency for accidents through accident forgiveness programs, which Progressive has for loyal policyholders and policyholders who purchase accident forgiveness.

Let’s examine Progressive’s average annual rates based on driving record

Driving Record SummaryProgressive Annual Rates
Based on Driving Record
Clean record$3,393.09
With 1 DUI$3,969.65
With 1 speeding violation$4,002.28
With 1 accident$4,777.04
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Progressive issues more expensive increases on a person’s record for accidents and speeding violations than DUI convictions. This is helpful for people in states where DUI convictions stay on their driving record for life. For those under SR-22 insurance, Progressive is likely to issue a higher-than-average rate.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Coverages Offered

As you’re shopping for car insurance, you’ll want to know what coverages will be available to you. The main parts of car insurance coverage are bodily injury and property damage. A lot of other car insurance coverage options do more. We’ll talk about those options from Progressive in this section as well as the essentials for car insurance coverage.

Types of Coverages Offered

Progressive has a variety of coverages: liability coverage, collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage. Progressive also has uninsured coverage, underinsured coverage, medical payments (often referred to as MedPay).  Ask the Progressive agent about Personal Injury Protection or PIP. PIP is required in some states, and you may see it attached to your policy.

The most important car insurance coverage offered is liability. Liability coverage is what all U.S. states and car insurers require for car insurance. It covers bodily injury and property damage.

Liability coverage carries a coverage limit, which determines how much your car insurance will cover in case you’re in a car accident. You can ask Progressive for a higher coverage limit if you think the minimum coverage limit isn’t enough to cover the cost of an accident.

What about full coverage?

Progressive experts say full coverage is a myth.

Full coverage is commonly known as the combination of liability coverage, collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage. When you’re financing or leasing a vehicle, the lender will ask you about full coverage, which is the combination of the three insurance coverages.

Comprehensive coverage provides protection in case your vehicle is damaged through unexpected events such as a fire, theft, vandalism, hitting an animal, glass breakage, or weather and acts of nature. You may have to pay a deductible.

A deductible is the amount of money you’ll pay out of pocket before your insurer pays the remaining balance.

Collision coverage pays for the cost of damage when your vehicle collides with another object such as a curb, trees, or another vehicle. If you have collision coverage with Progressive, they will pay veterinarian bills in case your pet is injured.

Uninsured and underinsured coverage is compensation after an accident with an at-fault driver who doesn’t have insurance or has coverage limits that don’t cover the cost of bodily injury or property damage.

Medical payment coverage is additional coverage for injuries regardless of who is at fault. It covers your family members and passengers in your vehicle. It also applies to you and family members who may be passengers in another vehicle or who are in an accident while they are walking or riding a bicycle.

What additional coverages does Progressive provide?

  • Roadside assistance — This coverage helps a policyholder in case their vehicle breaks down. Roadside assistance will get your car towed to your home or an auto repair shop of your choice.
  • Loan/lease payoff — Whenever your vehicle is a total loss after a car accident, Progressive will pay off the remaining balance of your loan or lease.
  • Rental car reimbursement — If you get into an accident and need a rental car to commute, Progressive will compensate you for any rental car fees and payments while your car is getting repaired.
  • Custom parts and equipment value — Cars that are customized with parts different than the original manufacturer can be insured with this coverage. Contact a Progressive agent to let them know which parts of your vehicle are customized, so they may add it to your policy.
  • Rideshare coverage — With ridesharing becoming popular, Progressive has adapted to this trend and offers ridesharers with insurance. If you’re in a car accident and you have sufficient coverage, Progressive will pay for a rental car (up to $30 to $50 per day) while your vehicle is being repaired (does not include routine maintenance).
  • Deductible savings — Concerned about deductibles? Progressive allows its policyholders to deposit money into a deductible savings account. This will allow policyholders to use their savings whenever they need to repair a windshield or whenever a deductible is required.

Progressive Bundling Options

On the Progressive homepage, you can get a quote for auto and home insurance, auto and renters insurance, and auto and condo insurance. Progressive has a lot more items you can insure for your convenience, and policyholders can receive discounts for bundling insurances together.

Here’s a commercial that shows how Progressive policyholders can bundle insurance, but in a very funny way.

Progressive Discounts

As you’ve seen from the Progressive commercials, Progressive promotes their savings. Their savings stem from the discounts policyholders and potential customers can receive under their policies.

What discounts are available at Progressive car insurance? We’ve seen the affordable rates based on driving record, coverage level, and commute mileage. Let’s take a look at more discounts that are available for Progressive policyholders.

Loyalty-Based Discounts

Policyholders who use Progressive services for car insurance and home insurance can receive a 5 percent or higher discount. Bundling your car insurance with another type of insurance at Progressive is one way to save money on your premium. Also, if you have multiple cars on one policy, Progressive will give you a 12 percent discount.

For those who continuously use Progressive as their insurance provider, Progressive will give them a discount. Progressive says that a policyholder’s discount for consistently insuring with Progressive depends on how long they’ve been insured with them without any gaps or cancellations.

Driver-Based Discounts

Teenage drivers who are 18 years old or younger are expensive to insure for car insurance. Progressive will help decrease teen driver insurance rates to help parents save money. The discount rate varies, so talk to a Progressive agent about eligibility.

If you’re a college student who wants to save money on car insurance, earning a B average or better could save you money with Progressive. This discount is also available to parents who have college students on their policy.

Like teen driver discounts, the good student discount rate varies. Students who live farther than 100 miles from their permanent residence are eligible for Progressive’s driver-based discount. Students who are 22 years old or younger are eligible, also.

What if a college student is on your policy and they don’t have a car while they’re in college? In that case, the policyholder would still be eligible for a distant student discount as long as the students are over 100 miles away from their permanent residence.

Speaking of residence, policyholders can receive up to 10 percent off their premiums if they have homeowners insurance, even if the home insurance provider isn’t with Progressive or their affiliates.

Discounts for How You Quote and Buy

Get a 4 percent discount if you purchase your policy using Progressive’s online quote generator. Progressive gives you further discounts when you go paperless (discount varies) and use the signup online feature (8.5 percent off). To get these discounts, you must e-sign (electronically sign) the necessary documents.

Progressive will give discounts to people who want to pay their premiums in full. The rate of this discount varies. Discounts are also given to people who set up automatic payments. Consult a Progressive agent on the discount rates, which could be different for each state, city, or county.

Progressive Programs

Progressive Advantage ® Business Program gives businesses access to different types of insurance products that typical small business owners need most. Progressive’s team of licensed agents can offer business owners policies, contractors liability, professional liability, cyber insurance and workers’ compensation underwritten by carriers selected by Progressive.

A program that relates to car insurance can save you money. Progressive has a usage-based insurance program called Snapshot®. The Snapshot® program tracks your driving performance and determines your premium rate based on how safe you drive. The safer you drive, the more money you’ll save.

Rating Agency

Before we move on to the annual rates for Progressive car insurance, let’s discuss how Progressive is rated by financial and credit agencies. Each agency has its own rating system.

Some groups don’t have a rating, but they use consumer feedback to judge whether the company or product is performing well for consumers.

Here are the ratings for Progressive from the top financial strength and credit rating agencies in the world.

Ratings AgencyRating
A.M. BestA+
Better Business BureauA-
Consumer Reports87
J.D. PowerClaims Satisfaction 3/5
Shopping Study 3/5
Moody'sAa
NAIC Complaint Index0.42 (2018)
S&PAA
Get Your Rates Quote Now

It appears that Progressive has good ratings from different agencies, but how do we know that for sure? This section will go into detail on what each grade means and explain where Progressive stands as a company based on the opinion of each major agency.

A.M. Best

A.M. Best is an international financial and credit rating agency that focuses on the insurance industry. A.M. Best’s credit ratings are an indicator of an insurance company’s financial strength and credit worth.

A.M. Best uses the Best Financial Strength Ratings, which is an independent opinion about an insurance company’s financial strength. In addition to the company’s financial strength and creditworthiness, A. M. Best judges an insurance company’s ability to meet policy and contract obligations.

Let’s review the grading scale of A.M. Best.

Rating CategoriesRating SymbolsRating NotchesCategory Definitions
SuperiorA+A++Assigned to insurance companies that have a superior ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations
ExcellentAA-Assigned to insurance companies that have an excellent ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations
GoodB+B++Assigned to insurance companies that have a good ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations
FairBB-Assigned to insurance companies that have a fair ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations. Financial strength is vulnerable to adverse changes in underwriting and economic conditions.
MarginalC+C++Assigned to insurance companies that have a marginal ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations. Financial strength is vulnerable to adverse changes in underwriting and economic conditions.
WeakCC-Assigned to insurance companies that have a weak ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations. Financial strength is very vulnerable to adverse changes in underwriting and economic conditions.
PoorD-Assigned to insurance companies that have a poor ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations. Financial strength is extremely vulnerable to adverse changes in underwriting and economic conditions.
Get Your Rates Quote Now

A.M. Best rates Progressive Corporation and its national affiliates with an A+ rating, which means Progressive has a superior ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations to their policyholders.

Better Business Bureau

The Better Business Bureau (BBB) grades the financial strength of a company, and they allow consumers to leave reviews about products and services. The BBB has a rating system also. The agency bases its grading on these factors:

  • Advertising issues
  • Business’s complaint history
  • Failure to honor commitments
  • Licensing and government actions
  • Type of business and time in business
  • Transparent business practices

What’s the BBB rating for companies? This table summarizes the grading system shown below and will explain how the BBB scores or rate each company.

BBB ScoreBBB Letter Rating
97-100A+
94-96.99A
90-93.99A-
87-89.99B+
84-86.99B
80-83.99B-
77-79.99C+
74-76.99C
70-73.99C-
67-69.99D+
64-66.99D
60-63.99D-
0-59.99F
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Progressive’s score is in the lower 90s and has a letter grade of A-, which is one of the highest ratings on the BBB grade scale. The customer ratings for Progressive, however, were low. Over 300 customer reviews gave Progressive a one-star rating.

Let’s continue through the guide to see ratings and customer reviews from other groups and agencies.

Moody’s Rating

Moody’s analyzes global capital markets and grades them based on their financial strength, performance, and credit worth. They provide credit ratings, research, tools, and analysis to financial markets.

Moody’s is one of the top credit-rating agencies.  This agency tracks credit ratings of companies in 135 countries. Their rating system is much different than its competitors, which we will show here:

Moody's Grading ScaleMoody's Grading Summary
AaaObligations are judged to be of the highest quality, subject to the lowest level of credit risk.
AaObligations are judged to be of high quality and are subject to very low credit risk.
AObligations are judged to be upper-medium grade and are subject to low credit risk.
BaaObligations are judged to be medium-grade and subject to moderate credit risk and as such may possess certain speculative characteristics.
BaObligations are judged to be speculative and are subject to substantial credit risk.
BObligations are considered speculative and are subject to high credit risk.
CaaObligations are judged to be speculative of poor standing and are subject to very high credit risk.
CaObligations are highly speculative and are likely in, or very near, default, with some prospect of recovery of principal and interest.
CObligations are the lowest rated and are typically in default, with little prospect for recovery of principal or interest.
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Moody’s rating of Progressive is Aa, which says that Progressive handled their obligations with high quality and was subject to very low credit risk.

S&P Rating

Standard and Poor’s is another international financial strength rating and credit rating agency that promotes transparency and business growth. S&P reports credit ratings, critical insights, and risk research that are essential to interpreting complexity into clear reports to help consumers make decisions.

S&P helps consumers through their rating system. Here are the grades they use to rate companies around the world and give consumers a clear view of who provides the best products and services.

Investment GradeInvest Grade Summary
AAAExtremely strong capacity to meet financial commitments
AAVery strong capacity to meet financial commitments
AStrong capacity to meet financial commitments, but somewhat susceptible to economic conditions and changes in circumstances
BBBAdequate capacity to meet financial commitments, but more subject to adverse economic conditions
BBLess vulnerable in the near-term but faces major ongoing uncertainties to adverse business, financial and economic conditions
BMore vulnerable to adverse business, financial and economic conditions but currently has the capacity to meet financial commitments
CCCCurrently vulnerable and dependent on favorable business, financial and economic conditions to meet financial commitments
CCHighly vulnerable; default has not yet occurred but is expected to be a virtual certainty
CCurrently highly vulnerable to non-payment, and ultimate recovery is expected to be lower than that of higher-rated obligations
DPayment default on a financial commitment or breach of an imputed promise and also used when a bankruptcy petition has been filed
Get Your Rates Quote Now

According to S&P, Progressive has a very strong capacity to meet financial obligations to its policyholders, giving the insurance company a grade of AA.

NAIC Complaint Index

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) reviews complaints from car insurance policyholders and reports the total number of complaints, premiums written and earned, and loss ratio to consumers as a way to promote transparency.

Consumer feedback is vital to any company’s success. Ratings from financial and credit rating agencies come from consumer feedback.

Progressive Report CriteriaComplaint Ratio
Annual national Median complaint ratio1.00
Progressive Insurance Corporation annual median complaint ratio0.36
Get Your Rates Quote Now

This report is from NAIC’s 2018 report of Progressive. It compares the national average complaint ratio with Progressive’s annual average of complaint ratio. Based on the averages, Progressive’s complaint ratio was 0.64 less than the national average.

What’s the complaint forecast for private passengers?

Private passengers are customers who insure their privately owned vehicles with a designated car insurance company.

The private passenger category is the voluntary insurance market where all policyholders take part in. The data in the table below describe Progressive’s complaint ratio and total complaints in the private passenger category.

Policy TypePrivate Passenger
Complaint year2018
Complaint index0.42
National median complaint index1.16
Complaint share0.003
Total complaints46
U.S. market share0.71%
Total premiums$1,748,548,733
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The complaint index for Progressive’s private passenger sector was 0.42. The national average complaint index for private passenger insurance was 1.16. Throughout 2018, Progressive only had 46 complaints in their private passenger department.

J.D. Power

J.D. Power reviews all companies based on a combination of financial strength and overall customer satisfaction review in a study called the U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study. This financial strength and credit agency uses something called the Power Circle Ratings and the customer satisfaction index. J.D. Power reviews companies by surveying customers of a company or product to rate various aspects of their service.

J.D. Power experts say, “All ratings are based on the opinions of consumers who have actually used or owned the product or service being rated.”

J.D. Power collects consumer feedback and releases it in its research reports. This research is called the Customer Satisfaction Index Ranking. The rankings are measured on a 1,000 point scale. The Power Circle Ratings are measured from:

  • Five out of five circle rating: Among the best
  • Four out of five circle rating: Better than most
  • Three out of five circle rating: About average
  • Two out of five circle rating: The rest

J.D. Power rates companies by region through independent studies conducted annually. For your convenience, we’ve listed each rating for Progressive in each region. Here are the results.

RegionCustomer Satisfaction
(out of 1,000)
J.D. Power Circle RankingJ.D. Power Circle Rating
California821About averageooo
Central823About averageooo
Florida809The restoo
Mid-Atlantic828The restooo
New England825About averageooo
New York815The restoo
North Central828About averageooo
Northwest797The restoo
Southeast824The restoo
Southwest807The restoo
Texas816The restoo
Get Your Rates Quote Now

J.D. Power rates Progressive in the upper 700s and mid 800s. Under the Power Circle Ratings, Progressive rates below average. As mentioned above, J.D. Power’s opinion is measured by customer satisfaction. Progressive appears to struggle between average to below-average in terms of customer satisfaction.

Consumer Reports

Consumer Report uses customer feedback to determine what company is right for the customer. If you’ve ever wondered about how other customers feel about a particular company, you can always search for Consumer Reports online. Consumer Reports tells you about such factors as the consumer experience with a company, customer service, and agent response time.

Here’s what we found out about Consumer Reports’ and customers’ opinions of Progressive car insurance.

Progressive Insurance GroupConsumer Report Stats
Reader Score87
Reaching an AgentVery Good
Simplicity of the ProcessVery Good
Promptness of ResponseVery Good
Damage AmountVery Good
Agent CourtesyVery Good
Timely PaymentExcellent
Freedom to Select Repair ShopVery Good
Being Kept Informed of Claim StatusVery Good
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Consumer Reports’ opinion differs from J.D. Power’s opinion greatly. Instead of the average and below-average evaluation, Consumer Report gives Progressive an excellent or very good rating. The reader’s score for Progressive is 87.

Company History

Progressive was established in 1937 by Joseph Lewis and Jack Green. They launched the Progressive Mutual Insurance Company to provide affordable auto insurance to all vehicle owners. Progressive encourages innovation and reinforces their drive to provide insurance protection at affordable prices.

Fifty years ago, Progressive was the first car insurance company that allowed policyholders to pay their car insurance premiums in installments.

Today, Progressive is one of the top 10 car insurance companies in the United States that not only provides car insurance, but also home insurance, renters insurance, and other services to policyholders. In recent years, they’ve seen an increase in company development.

Progressive Market Share

Progressive’s total sales have earned a spot on the top 10 list of best car insurance companies in the United States.

But where do they rank among the top 10 insurance companies? We’ve provided a summary of Progressive’s rank from 2015 to 2018. Here are the results:

YearProgressive RankProgressive Market Share
201548.7%
201649.15%
201739.84%
2018310.97%
Get Your Rates Quote Now

In 2015 and 2016, Progressive was ranked in fourth place, but in 2017 to 2018, they moved up to third. The market share for Progressive has gradually increased over four years.

Progressive’s Position for the Future

Based on the market share of Progressive, we see an increase in rank from 2015 to 2018. Could this increase continue? It depends on the company’s performance. Perhaps Progressive’s marketing and consumer strategies have improved the company’s policyholder acquisition rate. For now, it’s difficult to tell which direction Progressive will go.

How could that possible with Progressive earning higher profits each year? Even though Progressive has done well with premiums written, they advance more slowly than the competitors ranked above them. So far, Progressive has maintained a steady increase.

Progressive’s Online Presence

Progressive has a steady online presence. About 994,000 people follow them on Facebook, and they have 63,800 followers on Twitter. Progressive also has 25,300 subscribers on YouTube, while their Instagram account has 38,500 followers.

Progressive’s Commercials

Progressive uses humor, celebrities, and other witty displays to promote their company. Here are two commercials from Progressive that do just that. Most of the commercials appear to be geared more toward younger adults.

Progressive appears to be targeting college students and younger adults who are searching for car insurance.

Here’s another video showing another young adult who is determined to save money through Progressive auto insurance. Let’s watch the commercial.

Progressive continues to encourage young adults to abandon their parents’ car insurance policy and join Progressive to save money.

Progressive in the Community

The Keys to Progress ® Program honors veterans with vehicle donations to members of the U.S. Armed Forces. Progressive has donated more than 700 vehicles to veterans and veteran organizations since 2013. The one-day vehicle giveaway occurs every November.

Progressive employees across the country volunteer to find vehicles to donate, organize fundraising activities to collect money or goods for families, and plan memorable vehicle giveaway events for veterans.

STEM Progress ® Program stands for science, technology, engineering, and math education programs. Progressive employees contribute to the causes they care about through the Progressive Insurance Foundation, which was established in 2001. The foundation gives back to communities by supporting charities.

Progressive considers any qualified civic, cultural, educational, environmental, health care, human services, or religious 501(c)(3) public, tax-exempt charitable organization as eligible under the STEM Progress ® program.

The Progressive Corporation contributes to the Progressive Insurance Foundation every year. When an employee gives any amount from $20 to $3,000 to a qualified 501(c)(3) charity and requests a matching gift, the foundation matches the employee’s dollars up to 100 percent, depending on the number of requests and the company’s performance.

Progressive’s Employees

Progressive’s employee experience is rated as one of the highest among insurance companies. In 2019, Progressive was ranked fifth in Financial Services & Insurance™ Best Workplaces, and it ranked 76th in the Fortune 100 Best Companies to Work For®.

According to Great Place to Work, the overall employee experience at Progressive has a 92 percent approval rating. Great Place to Work is a nonprofit group that allows current and former employees to anonymously rate their workplace. The group analyzes each factor of a company. For Progressive, five areas were praised by employees.

Great Place to Work Review - Progressive InsuranceEmployee Satisfaction Score
Overall employee experience92%
Welcoming newcomers97%
Honest & ethical management94%
Professional executive staff93%
Resources93%
Proud to work for the company93%
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Ninety-seven percent of employees felt welcome when they joined, while 94 percent praised the honesty and ethics of management. Executives, resources, and pride about the job were given a 93 percent approval rating.

What’s the average age of employees at Progressive?

The largest age group at Progressive are millennials (born between 1981 and 1997), which make up 47 percent of employees. Thirty-nine percent of employees are Gen-X’ers (born between 1965 and 1980), and the remaining 13 percent are baby boomers (born between 1945 and 1964).

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Canceling Your Progressive Policy

If you want to cancel your policy with Progressive, there are few things you should know. This section of the Progressive guide will explain how to cancel your car insurance policy and set up another insurance so your car can remain insured.

Cancellation Fee

Some states have laws that require car insurance companies to issue a cancellation fee whenever a policyholder cancels their insurance policy. Car insurance companies will normally ask for the remaining balance on your policy before you cancel.

Is there a refund?

Policyholders who have prepaid their car insurance will be issued a refund for car insurance services not used.

How to Cancel a Progressive Policy

For Progressive policyholders to cancel their policy, they’ll have to contact a Progressive associate, which can be done through their toll-free number at 1 (866) 416-2003. Be sure to have your policy number close by. They’ll want to ask a few questions on why you want to cancel. Associates will evaluate whether you’re eligible for other discounts, and they’ll ask about the next car insurance company you’ll be insured with.

Policyholders may be able to cancel their policies on the website when they login to their account, but it’s safer to cancel with a Progressive associate.

When can I cancel?

You can cancel anytime you see fit. It’s better to cancel once you have another car insurance policy ready to use.

How to Make a Claim

If you’re already a Progressive policyholder, you can make a claim by calling Progressive’s toll-free service, submitting it online or using the Progressive mobile app.

There are two options for making a claim. One of them is reporting vehicle damage, and the other is reporting windshield and glass damage.

When you make a claim, be sure to have your account/policy number ready. Keep a physical copy of your Progressive information in your vehicle and an electronic copy on your smartphone.

Once you’ve submitted your claim, Progressive associates will inspect the damage and give you repair options. They’ll help schedule repairs as well. When the repairs are complete, your claim will be resolved.

Claims for windshield and glass repair follow the same procedure.

Ease of Making a Claim

Using the toll-free service or the Progressive mobile app is the easiest way to make a claim. It may inconvenient for policyholders to login to make a claim, especially if they haven’t logged in through the website before.

Direct Premiums Written

Premiums written represent the total premiums written in a company within a period. This could be from the company itself or any other affiliated companies. The main factor for a car insurance company’s direct premium success is when new policies are written.

YearProgressive RankProgressive Direct Premiums Written
20154$16,566,932
20164$19,634,834
20173$22,786,034
20183$27,058,768
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Progressive’s direct premiums written increased from 2015 to 2018, which increased their ranking among the major insurance companies in the United States. Since 2015, Progressive has increased its direct premiums written by about $11 million.

Loss Ratio

The loss ratio represents the number of claims paid out versus the number of premiums received from policyholders.

The loss ratio is money being paid out in claims from a car insurance company and the money they earned from policyholders.

If a car insurance company, for example, has a loss ratio of 71.21, it means the company spent $71.21 for every $100 they made.

Loss ratios that are too low indicate a car insurance company that doesn’t pay out claims effectively, and loss ratios that are too high or exceed 100 indicate a car insurance company that isn’t earning money.

YearProgressive RankProgressive Loss Ratio
2015464.23
2016466.74
2017363.32
2018362
Get Your Rates Quote Now

The loss ratio for Progressive stayed around 65 from 2015 to 2016. By 2017, the loss ratio saw its first decrease, and in 2018, the loss ratio dropped to 62. When we average all the loss ratios in the four-year trend, we’ll see that Progressive had an average loss ratio of 64.07.

How to Get a Quote Online

Now that you’ve seen what the average annual rates are like for Progressive, you’re probably wondering what it would be like for you. You can a direct quote from Progressive through their website. In this section, we’ll give you some a step-by-step guide on how you can do that.

Below is the Progressive homepage.

Progressive auto insurance quote welcome page

To get started, click on the car icon under “Better insurance starts here.”

Step 1: Choose Your Insurance Option

You’re welcome to bundle your insurance, but for this example, we’ll stick with auto.

Progressive auto insurance quote zip code entry

Enter your ZIP code and click the “Get a Quote” button to continue.

Step 2: Enter Name, Birthdate & Address

Progressive will need to know some information about you before you can move on.

Progressive auto insurance quote personal information

Enter your name, date of birth, and mailing address. When you’re done, click “Okay, start my quote” to continue.

Step 3: Enter Information About Your Vehicle

The next step is entering your vehicle information. Progressive will ask about the make, model, and body type of the vehicle.

Progressive auto insurance quote vehicle information

In addition to technical vehicle details, the site will ask you how you’ll use the vehicle, and if you own or lease the vehicle. Finally, the section will ask how long you’ve driven the vehicle.

Step 4: Enter Information Driver Information

The next section of the quote process is entering your driver information. This will give Progressive more information about your gender, education level, and occupation.

Progressive auto insurance quote additional personal information

You don’t have to use your Social Security number (SSN). We didn’t enter an SSN for this step and we were able to proceed to the next step.

You’ll have to respond to a few more items in the quote process, which is relevant to how much your quote will be.

Progressive auto insurance quote personal information

Double-check your information before you move on to the other responses.

Progressive will ask about whether you own or rent your residence, and they’ll want to know about your driving history.

Progressive auto insurance quote residence information

Answer each dialog box and bullet point accurately. It could be a problem later in your policy if you didn’t answer one of the questions accurately.

Continue to follow the responses and prompt until you get to this screen.

Progressive auto insurance quote add a driver

Once you’ve completed all the information required, click “Continue.”

Step 5: Verify Additional Personal Information

Progressive’s quote responses will double-check your information to make sure it’s accurate.

Progressive auto insurance quote information verification

 

Look through the information to see if anything is missing. If everything is accurate, continue through the Progressive quote process.

Step 6: Report Insurance History

You’ll need to provide Progressive with information about your insurance history and e-mail address.

Progressive auto insurance quote insurance history

When you’ve completed this section, click continue.

If you scroll down, you’ll see more information that’s required.

Progressive auto insurance quote history with Progressive

Enter your primary email address and how many people live with you in the household, then click “Continue.”

Step 7: Choose to Enroll in Additional Services

Before you move on to your quote, Progressive will ask if you want to sign up with Snapshot ®.

Progressive auto insurance quote Progressive Snapshot

It’s optional, so you can simply click continue and skip the signup process.

Step 8: Choose to Bundle with Another Insurance

After the Snapshot ® sign-up screen, you’ll have another chance to bundle your auto insurance with other insurance that Progressive offers.

Progressive auto insurance quote bundling options

We’ve decided to skip the bundle option for this step-by-step guide.

Step 9: Select Your Quote

Finally, the last part is your quote. You’ll see three selections you can choose from.

Progressive auto insurance quote package choice

Below the “Start your policy today for”, you’ll see how much you’ll pay in the next five months with the total in parentheses.

As you scroll through the quote webpage, you’ll see options to edit the type of coverages you need.

Progressive auto insurance quote coverage review

The information you entered in the previous steps will be listed on the right.

If you’re satisfied with what you see, you can submit your information and click the “Finish & Buy” button at the bottom.

Progressive auto insurance quote finish and buy insurance

Progressive holds up to its promise of providing cheap car insurance rates as seen in the quoted price.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Design of Website and App

Website design can be a deterrent for customers. Slow wait times, too much text, and over-the-top interactivity on icons and text can frustrate web surfers, especially those who are searching for information.

Where does Progressive stand on website design? Before we talk about it, let’s take another look at Progressive’s introduction webpage.

Progressive auto insurance quote welcome page

Some of the answers can be difficult to find despite having an answers tab at the top of the webpage. The Progressive website has some complexity to it, which might deter or distract a visitor. For example, the search box is close to the bottom of the homepage. So finding an answer could be frustrating.

Is the design a plus or minus?

There are certain areas on the website that take you directly to what you’re looking for. The design may be user-friendly to some, but may not be to others. Giving users or visitors options to choose their specifics is helpful, but it would be equally helpful if they didn’t have to scroll through the page to locate the search bar.

Mobile App

What’s it like for those who use Progressive’s mobile app? Here’s a screenshot of Progressive’s mobile app download and screenshots of the Progressive app on the iPhone.

Progressive auto insurance quote iPhone app

 

How easily can you manage your account using just the app?

Mobile apps are built for the user’s convenience. Everything a policyholder could do on the internet can be done on the mobile app. You can make payments, make claims, and check your car insurance information.

Is the design a plus or minus?

The design is a plus for policyholders. Access to their policy information and payment information will allow them to view anything they need right away.

Progressive Car Insurance Pros and Cons

To be truly objective in our analysis of Progressive car insurance, we have to look at the pros and cons of the company. Customer reviews are subjective, and they vary for each individual.

Let’s review the pros and cons of Progressive based on facts we’ve seen thus far and what available for policyholders and potential customers.

Progressive Car Insurance ProsProgressive Car Insurance Cons
Discounts for teen and college student driversAll states don't receive the same discounts
Policyholders have 24/7 access to customer service and claimsHigher than average rates for policyholders with poor or fair credit
Accurate quote processingBelow Average and Average J.D. Power ratings
Additional car insurance coverage for any situationSnapshot app can increase rates if your driving is habits are risky.
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Although Progressive has several discounts that are helpful to its policyholders, they don’t offer discounts in all states. The discounts that are available to policyholders help save thousands per year. Progressive has below average to average ratings from financial and credit rating agencies, but they make up for it in there 24/7 claim service, which shows the company’s eagerness to improve in areas where they lack.

The Bottom Line

Progressive has earned its place among the top 10 insurance providers. Although the rates are more expensive than some car insurance companies, Progressive makes up for it through discounts and policy flexibility. We see that in the increasing premiums written and market share. The company’s commitment to customers and employees has given them a major boost.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Progressive Car Insurance FAQs

Before we end the guide, we want to answer some general questions some of our readers have about Progressive. If there’s a question we missed, use our comment section to ask a question, and we’ll answer it to the best of our knowledge.

What is accident forgiveness, and does Progressive provide it?

Accident forgiveness is when a car insurance company decides not to increase car insurance rates when a policyholder has an accident. Progressive provides this service for policyholders who pay for it and provide a discount to policyholders who have been with the company for longer than a year.

Does comprehensive coverage cover storm damage?

Yes. Storm damage counts as an unexpected event. Take photos of the damage to better prove your claim.

How long does high-risk driver status last?

Some high-risk drivers have to enroll in SR-22 car insurance, which can last up to three years. After this period, car insurance companies may not consider you to be a high-risk driver, and you’ll be eligible for the voluntary market. However, it will be up to the insurance company to determine whether you’re a high-risk driver.

What is low-cost insurance?

Low-cost insurance is state-sponsored or state-funded car insurance for those who can’t afford the average annual rate for car insurance. Only three states offer low-cost insurance: California, Hawaii, and New Jersey.

What is personal injury protection? Does Progressive provide it?

Personal injury protection (PIP) is further medical compensation after an accident. What’s special about PIP is that it covers lost wages, mental health payments, other related medical payments. Progressive does provide it. In some states, PIP is required.

Ready to find the best rates in your area? Use the free quote box below by entering your ZIP code and clicking the “Get Quotes” button.

Are you looking for free insurance quotes?

Your one-stop online Car Insurance guide. Get a Free Quote Now!

(855) 898-5028