Auto Insurance for High Risk Drivers

While auto insurance can be expensive, it doesn’t have to be. Even those labeled as “high risk” or “risky” can still find affordable auto coverage. As always, shopping around for the best deal is your best bet for finding affordable auto insurance for high risk drivers. Continue reading below to learn all about this high risk designation and how you can still save on car insurance even if you are deemed to be high risk.

auto insurance for high risk drivers

What Is A High Risk Driver?

The short explanation of a high risk driver is one who poses a high financial risk to the auto insurance company. In other words, someone who is likely to cost them money. There are typically two different classifications of high risk drivers.

The most common type of high risk driver is the younger, inexperienced driver. Often times, teenage drivers fit this bill. Statistically speaking, these drivers are more likely to be involved in accidents that cause injuries and/or high amounts of property damage. Assuming these young drivers maintain a clean driving record, they will likely see a rate decrease around their 25th birthday, when most auto insurance providers stop considering them to be high risk.

The second group of high risk drivers consists of DUI offenders, those with multiple speeding tickets, and accident-prone drivers. If you fit into any of these categories, congratulations! You are a high risk driver in the eyes of insurance companies.

Why Do High Risk Drivers Have To Pay More For Auto Insurance?

The name says it all. These drivers are very risky, and often times expensive to insure. This is because the chance of the insurance provider having to pay for repairs, medical bills, and property damage is much higher. In order to cover themselves financially, they must charge higher rates to those more likely to wind up in an accident.

What Do Insurance Companies Deem To Be Risky?

To get a better idea of who is a high risk driver and who isn’t, picture these two examples:

Driver #1

  • Male aged 17
  • His dad bought him a Ford Mustang
  • Drives this car to school and to work. He also likes to “race” with his friends on the highway.
  • Already has two speeding tickets (he has been driving for less than a year)
  • Arrested for driving under the influence. Depending on the outcome of his trial, he might get his license revoked.

Driver #2

  • Female aged 45
  • She is an elementary school teacher
  • Her children are away at college, so the only people on her policy at home are her and her husband.
  • Never had a traffic violation or an accident

Now ask yourself – if you were an insurance company, who would you rather insure?

Save Money On High Risk Auto Insurance

Proving to the auto insurance companies that you are in fact a safe and responsible driver can go a long way when it comes to saving on high risk auto coverage. Luckily there are many ways to do this. The most popular and effective way to do so is to take a defensive or safe driving course, which you can find more information on from your local DMV office.

A car with a good safety reputation and all the latest safety devices will also reduce the risk you pose to your insurance provider. Such safety devices include automatic seat belts, anti-lock breaks, and airbags. Fast or “tricked out” cars are a definite no-no for high risk drivers, and driving such a car can greatly increase your premiums.

Best Insurance Companies For High Risk Drivers

If you are a high risk driver or you are looking for auto insurance for someone else who would be considered a high risk driver, it stands to reason that you want to ensure you are getting the best coverage possible; and that you are getting the most affordable rates, too.

To help you find insurance coverage that you can rely on to ensure you meet the legal requirements – and to protect you from having to pay an exorbitant amount of money – we’ve put together a list of the best insurance companies for high risk drivers. Whether you have been in multiple accidents, have several tickets, are a teen driver, or are an older driver, the following companies are excellent options to consider for your auto insurance needs:

  • Bristol West. This insurance provider is a subsidiary of the seventh biggest car insurance company in the United States: Farmers Insurance. This carrier is highly regarded and offers excellent rates on liability coverage for high risk drivers. They have an excellent track record and a firm standing, financially speaking. In addition to offering affordable rates, Bristol West also provides options for low down payments on liability coverage, as well as payment options that are flexible and can meet a driver’s specific needs.
  • GEICO Casualty. GEICO Casualty is a subsidiary of GEICO that is specifically intended for high risk drivers. What makes this carrier so great for high risk drivers is that they use a clear and very easy to understand point system to figure out how much you will pay for your auto insurance policy. This point system is based on how many accidents a driver has been involved in (and how frequently accidents have occurred), reckless driving, and the type of coverages that are chosen. In terms of customer satisfaction and rates for high risk drivers, GEICO Casualty has received outstanding reviews.
  • Progressive. When Progressive first started, they were an insurance company that offered insurance exclusively for high risk drivers. This carrier was the very first to allow drivers to pay premiums in installments instead of in a lump sum, and they still allow you to do so, which makes their rates very affordable for high risk drivers. Progressive also provides drive-in claims services. This carrier has received outstanding reviews for customer services, as well as claims processing since they first started. Furthermore, the process of having a car repaired in the event that a claim is made is very simple compared to other insurance companies.
  • Titan Insurance. As a subsidiary of Nationwide, one of the largest car insurance providers in the United States, Titan Insurance is an excellent option for high risk drivers. That’s because they offer insurance coverage for high risk drivers that other carriers would never consider covering; for example, drivers who have a history of DUI convictions. They also provide the drivers they cover with SR-22 paperwork if it is needed. If you’re looking for the least expensive coverage possible, you’ll like that Titan offers a variety of minimum coverage options. They also offer several discounts that can make a big difference to the cost of your premiums, such as a discount for driving a vehicle with anti-lock brakes.
  • State Farm. Last, but certainly not least, of the best auto insurance companies for high risk drivers is State Farm. Not only does this carrier offer affordable plans for drivers who are considered a high risk, but they also offer their specialized Drive Safe and Save program, which keeps tabs on your driving to determine how safe you are driving and offers discounts according to the information they collect; for example, if you are braking properly, you may be eligible for a discount.

How Do I Know If I’m Considered A Risky Investment?

Most people don’t find out they are high risk driver until they’ve been declined coverage by a number of auto insurance companies. But there are some easy ways to determine if you are a high risk driver before even getting a quote.

DUI/DWI – If you have a DUI or a DWI on your driving record within the last 10 years or so, chances are you will be considered a high risk driver. Taking driver improvement classes and alcohol or addiction classes may improve your chances of finding an auto insurance policy.

Young Drivers With Bad Records – If you’ve been driving for a very short time, and already have a number of tickets and accidents on your record, you will definitely be considered a high risk driver. Unfortunately, your age is outside of your control. There is nothing you can do about it but stay safe behind the wheel and wait until you’re older. Taking defensive driving and/or driver’s ed classes will help you alleviate some of the cost burdens, however.

Fast/Expensive Cars – Even if you have a clean driving record, an expensive, high-performance car may lump you into the high risk driver category. A good way to counteract this, if you are unwilling to drive a less flashy car, is to make sure your car is loaded with safety features.

Finding High Risk Car Insurance

Even if you are considered to be a high risk driver, you should still be able to find a company to insure you. Most large auto insurance companies will be happy to insure you for an above-market rate. There are also many auto insurance companies, as detailed above, that specialize in high risk drivers.

If you are applying for quotes online, most quote comparison tools will be able to automatically determine your risk level after you’ve entered your driving history into their form. As a result, you will only be presented with premium estimates from companies willing to insure high risk individuals.

As a high risk driver, if you wish to give yourself the best chance at finding affordable car insurance, you’ll need to get quotes from as many companies as possible. At, we make that process easy for you. Simply enter your zip code in the form above to be taken to our quote comparison form. After filling out our brief questionnaire, you’ll be connected to multiple insurers willing to insure you for reasonable rates.


  Comments: 7

  1. Andrew Jenkins

    Honestly, I think that it would be wise to get insurance. We will never know when and where are we going to have an accident. This sure says a lot, very informative blog.

  2. The article above makes it sound like you can get cheap auto insurance even if you are high risk. let me say this “cheap high risk auto insurance” is an oxymoron. Anybody irresponsible enough to have a poor enough driving record to be deemed “high risk” doesn’t get the liberty of getting cheap insurance.

    If you really want cheap insurance, you need to drive safely and not be stupid behind the wheel and get things like DUI’s and speeding tickets. Cheap auto insurance is a privilege, not a right.

    • What about the person doing the right thing and the other guy is wrong but you still get charged because it is still an accident. They do not care who is at fault. So you get charge as “high risk “. Not fair.

    • And also I drive for a living so I have to be in areas where if I wasn’t working I wouldn’t be caught dead in these areas at rush hour. So I am stuck between the rock and a hard place!

    • Armando@4AutoInsuranceQuote

      Hi Johnny,

      You’re not wrong, being labeled as a high-risk driver is pretty much guaranteeing more expensive coverage rates. However, this article focuses on saving a high-risk driver money relative to their situation. That is to say, the cheapest option among the options available. The article does offer some good suggestions as well, such as the type of vehicle to choose and to avoid modifications to keep rates lower than they would be otherwise. As Steven’s post mentions however, if you are involved in an accident (or a few) you may be classified at a higher risk than other drivers that have not been in accidents (because of your apparent failure to avoid them) even if you are not at fault for any of them. Not everybody that has been in an accident necessarily made poor driving decisions, yet they are stuck with higher rates.

  3. WHAT if let’s say your a tow truck driver and you get into a wreck and it’s your fault. Your LISCENCE is revoked and yu try to pass your
    ID off as DL. What would happen to you and your Company?

    • Armando@4AutoInsuranceQuote


      It would be a very, very poor decision to try and do this. Your ID CANNOT be used as a driver’s license, because it is not a driver’s license. The minute that you’re pulled over for anything as minor as a routine traffic stop, you will likely be arrested and your truck will be impounded, racking up penalties and storage fees until it’s eventually auctioned if you don’t recover it. Furthermore, an insurer would likely not cover an accident if they found out you were driving with a revoked license. To state the obvious, your business will go underwater if nobody is driving the truck. Therefore my suggestion to you is to hire an employee to legally drive for you in the meantime and consider consulting with a lawyer to see if anything can be done about your revoked license.

Your feedback